top of page

What is Critical Thinking?

Oct 11
7 min read

You see a post saying that a new game is brilliant. Your friend says it is boring. An advert says that almost everyone loves it.


Who should you believe? Before choosing a side, it helps to ask what each person is basing their answer on.


Critical thinking means checking the reasons and evidence before deciding what to believe or do.


You can use it when reading a news story, buying something, solving a problem or deciding whether to share a message. You do not need to know all the answers. You need a way to ask useful questions.


Three steps for critical thinking: pause, check the evidence, and decide what it supports.

Pause, check and decide. Give yourself time to look at the evidence before reaching an answer.


Start with three simple words

A claim is something someone says is true. For example: "This game helps children learn new words."


Evidence is information that helps us check a claim. In this example, we would want to know whether children learned new words after playing, and how that was measured.


A conclusion is the answer we reach after looking at the evidence. We might decide that the claim is well supported, that it is wrong, or that we do not yet know enough.


These are different things. A confident claim is not evidence on its own. And even a real piece of evidence may not support everything someone says about it.


An everyday example: "9 out of 10 liked it"

Imagine an advert for a board game. It says: "9 out of 10 people liked this game." That sounds impressive. But a few details could change what the number tells us.


Imaginary survey showing nine positive answers and one negative answer, with the question: But who was asked?

This is an imaginary survey. Nine positive answers tell us about the people who answered. We still need to know who they were and how they were chosen.


Suppose the company asked ten people who belonged to the game's fan club. Nine said they liked it. The number may be correct, but the group was already likely to enjoy the game.


Now suppose an independent researcher asks a larger mix of players, including people who tried the game and stopped playing. That could give us a more useful picture of different experiences.


A bigger survey is not automatically a better survey. Asking thousands of fans can still leave out people who disliked the game. We also need to check who was asked and what question they answered.


The useful question is: "Does this evidence tell us what we want to know?"


Five questions to help you think it through

1. What exactly is being claimed?

Turn a vague statement into a clear question. "This is the best game" might mean the cheapest, the funniest or the easiest to learn. Those are different claims.


A personal preference, such as "This is my favourite game", is also different from a claim we can test, such as "This game costs less than the others."


2. What is the evidence?

Look for something you can examine: the original survey, a measurement, a document, or a clear account of what happened. Ask whether it supports this particular claim.


A photograph of someone holding a game shows that they held it. It does not, by itself, show that they enjoyed it or learned from it.


3. Where did the information come from?

Find the original source if you can. Who produced it? Do they know about the subject? Do they explain how they reached their answer?


Check the date and the full context too. An old notice saying the library is closed does not tell you whether it is closed today. A screenshot may leave out the date or the sentences around it.


Several websites repeating the same story are not necessarily several separate pieces of evidence. They may all be copying one original claim.


4. Could there be another explanation?

Imagine finding a wet pavement. You might think it has rained. But someone could have washed the pavement, or a water pipe could be leaking.


The wet ground is real evidence. It does not tell you the cause on its own. Looking at the sky, nearby puddles or a leaking pipe would help you choose between explanations.


5. What would make me change my mind?

Ask this about your own view as well as someone else's. If you think a game is too expensive, a price comparison might change your mind. If you think a message is current, finding its original date might change it.


You can also say: "I do not know yet." Waiting for better information is often more useful than guessing and sounding certain.


What is a cognitive bias?

A cognitive bias is a pattern in our thinking that can pull our judgement in a particular direction. We may notice some information easily and overlook other information.


For example, confirmation bias can make us favour information that fits what we already believe. We might pay less attention to evidence that challenges our view.


Imagine that you have decided to buy a particular pair of headphones. You read the five-star reviews carefully, but skip the reviews describing faults. You may be building a case for your choice instead of checking it fairly.


A useful next step is to look for reliable information on both the strengths and the weaknesses. Apply the same checks to a review you like and one you dislike.



How is a logical fallacy different?

A logical fallacy is a mistake in the way an argument is put together. The problem is the link between the reasons someone gives and the answer they want us to accept.


Imagine Sam says: "The timetable says the bus leaves at four." Someone replies: "Sam is terrible at football, so that cannot be right."


Sam's football skills do not tell us when the bus leaves. We need to check the timetable. Attacking an unrelated feature of the person avoids the actual question.


A bias can affect what we notice or believe. A fallacy is a problem in the reasoning used to support a claim. The two can overlap, but they are not the same thing.


Spotting a fallacy does not prove that the claim itself is false. A person can reach a correct answer for a poor reason. The answer still needs to be checked.



Clear words make clearer thinking

People sometimes disagree because they are using the same word in different ways. Before arguing about whether something is "fair", "safe" or "successful", ask what the word means in that conversation.


Imagine two people planning a school event. One calls it a success because many people came. The other is disappointed because it raised little money. They are using different measures of success.


Once they explain those meanings, they can ask clearer questions: How many people attended? How much money was raised? What was the event meant to achieve?


Critical thinking also means being fair

Thinking critically does not mean finding fault with everything or disagreeing with everyone. It means giving a claim the care it deserves, including claims you already agree with.


You do not have to give every idea equal weight. Strong, relevant evidence should count for more than a rumour. Someone with the right expertise can help, especially when they explain the evidence behind their advice.


Listen carefully, ask a clear question and explain your reasons. You can take someone's feelings seriously while still checking whether a factual claim is correct.


Try it with one message today

Choose a claim from an advert or a message. Write down exactly what it says. Then ask:


  • What evidence would help me check it?

  • Can I find the original source and its date?

  • Is there important information missing?

  • What can I reasonably conclude, and what is still unclear?


You do not need to investigate every small choice for hours. Give more care to decisions that matter more, and pause before passing an unverified claim on to other people.


Explore the idea through play

Thinky: a short challenge about one bias

Thinky is our free beta prototype. It explores one idea, survivorship bias: the mistake of looking only at the examples that made it through and overlooking the ones that did not.


Actual Thinky 0.3.1 prototype screen showing damage on returning aircraft and the instruction to fit armour.

An actual Thinky 0.3.1 prototype screen. You choose where to place armour on the aircraft. This is an early proof of concept.


In the challenge, you look at damage on aircraft that returned and choose where to put protective armour. The important question is: what can the aircraft that returned tell us, and what evidence might be missing?


The prototype offers a short, brain-training-style activity. It is still being developed and tested. It is designed as a way to explore the idea, and we will need to evaluate its learning benefits as it develops.


Willowwind: a future island adventure

Willowwind is a separate concept for people who enjoy longer play sessions, stories and exploration. The aim is to build critical-thinking questions into an adventure.


For example, a future quest might ask you to investigate why a village well has run dry. Different characters could offer different explanations. You would need to compare their accounts, look for evidence and decide what to investigate next.


That is a hypothetical example of the intended approach, not a feature of a finished game. Further development is planned after Project Empathy is completed, with professional game-development support.


The shared aim is to make careful thinking something people can practise and explore.



On that page, you can also sign up for occasional emails about the bias trainer and island game, including progress, testing and launch news.


Sources and further reading





The board-game survey, headphones, timetable, school event and village-well examples are invented to explain the ideas. The graphics were created for this article. The Thinky image shows our prototype.


This article updates Spaceship Earth's introduction first published on 28 January 2020.


 
 
bottom of page