What is genocide? The Holocaust, the Blitz and the war at sea
During the Holocaust, Nazi Germany, its allies and collaborators murdered six million Jewish men, women and children. During the Second World War, German planes also bombed British towns and cities. German submarines sank ships carrying food and other supplies to Britain.
All of these events caused terrible suffering. But they were not all the same kind of act.
The Holocaust was genocide. The Blitz and the submarine campaign against Britain were not genocide. To understand why, we need to look at what the attackers were trying to do.
This is not a way of saying that one person's life mattered more than another's. It is a way of naming different crimes accurately.
This article examines the Holocaust, the Blitz and the submarine campaign against Britain, using historical evidence and the legal meaning of genocide.
Start with the meaning of genocide
Genocide means carrying out certain harmful acts with the aim of destroying a group of people, in whole or in part. People are targeted because they belong to that group.
The Genocide Convention is an international treaty adopted by the United Nations in 1948. It defines genocide and requires countries that join it to prevent and punish the crime. Read the Convention.
A treaty is an agreement between countries that creates legal duties. From here, we will call this treaty the Convention.
The Convention protects four kinds of group: national, ethnic, racial and religious. These words cover groups connected by nationality, shared background, the idea of race, or religion. They do not mean any group we might choose to join, such as a football club.
The law does not treat racist ideas as true. For example, the Nazis falsely claimed that Jews were a separate, dangerous race. They used this lie to justify persecution.
For the crime of genocide, the people responsible must carry out at least one of the acts listed in the Convention, with the aim of destroying the protected group, in whole or in part. The United Nations explains the definition here.
The law looks at both the action and its aim
The Convention lists five kinds of act. In simple words, they are:
1. Killing people in the group.
2. Causing serious harm to their bodies or minds.
3. Deliberately imposing conditions meant to physically destroy the group, in whole or in part. This can include depriving people of food.
4. Taking steps to stop people in the group having children.
5. Forcibly taking the group's children and placing them in another group.
These acts count as genocide when they are done with the aim of destroying the group, in whole or in part. Genocide can happen during a war or in peacetime. Read the five acts in the Genocide Convention.
The word intent means what someone means to do. For genocide, the required intent is to destroy the group itself, in whole or in part. A wish to take land or force a government to surrender does not, by itself, establish that intent. Other aims can exist alongside an intent to destroy a group, so we must examine the evidence.
There does not have to be a plan to kill every member everywhere. An attempt to destroy a substantial part of a group can be genocide. “Substantial” means a significant part, judged in its wider setting. The International Court of Justice explains this in its genocide judgment.
The Holocaust: people targeted for being Jewish
Before the Holocaust, Jewish communities existed across Europe. They included children, parents, grandparents, friends and neighbours. People went to school, worked, worshipped and made plans for the future.
When the Nazis came to power in Germany in 1933, they began taking away the rights of Jews. They spread lies about them and pushed them out of public life. Many Jewish families tried to escape.

Jewish refugee children at Harwich, England, in December 1938. They had left Germany to escape Nazi persecution. Photo: Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-1987-0928-501. CC BY-SA 3.0 DE. Original archive scan; no changes.
The children in this photograph reached England in 1938. This was before the war began. Their journey helps us see that the history started with real families facing growing danger.
During the war, persecution grew into a vast programme of murder. Nazi Germany, its allies and collaborators murdered six million Jews. Collaborators were people who helped the Nazis carry out their policies and crimes. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum gives an overview of the Holocaust.
Why the Holocaust was genocide
Jews were not targeted because they had all committed some act. They were targeted because they were Jewish.
The Nazis hunted down children and older people as well as adults. They attacked Jewish communities in many countries. They were not simply trying to defeat an army. Their aim was to murder Europe's Jews.
The murders happened in several ways. Mobile killing units shot whole communities. Other victims were sent to killing centres, where they were murdered. The Nazis called their plan the “Final Solution”. Those words hid its real meaning: the murder of Europe's Jews. Read the museum's account of the Final Solution.
We know about the plan from many kinds of evidence. These include orders, official records, reports of killings and accounts from people who survived.
The Wannsee meeting in January 1942 is one example. Officials discussed how to organise the plan across Europe. Mass murder had already begun, so the meeting did not start the Holocaust. It helped officials work together to carry it out. Read about the Wannsee meeting and its surviving record.
The Blitz: trying to force Britain to give up
The Blitz was a series of German bombing raids on Britain. Its main period lasted from September 1940 to May 1941. London was attacked, along with cities such as Coventry, Liverpool and Plymouth.
Bombs hit homes and streets as well as docks, factories and other targets. More than 40,000 civilians were killed during the Blitz. A civilian is someone who is not a member of the armed forces.

British troops clear bomb damage in Birkenhead on 15 March 1941, during the Blitz. Photo: Lt Taylor, War Office official photographer / Imperial War Museums, H 8138. Public domain.
The photograph shows troops clearing wreckage in Birkenhead. Behind a phrase such as “bomb damage” were people who had lost homes, neighbours and family members. Imperial War Museums sets out the dates and scale of the Blitz.
Germany wanted to damage Britain's ability to fight. It also hoped that fear and destruction would break people's willingness to keep going. This is often called breaking morale.
These aims help explain the attacks. They do not excuse them. Historic England explains how the Blitz was intended to force Britain to surrender.
British people are a national group, so the genocide definition could apply to an attempt to destroy them. But the historical evidence shows that the Blitz aimed to force Britain to surrender. It does not establish an aim to destroy British people as a group.
That is why the Blitz did not meet the definition of genocide. This does not make its civilian victims any less important.
What about the laws of war?
Attacking a military target is different from deliberately attacking civilians to frighten a country into surrender. The Blitz included attacks intended to break civilian morale. Explaining that aim does not excuse attacking civilians.
In June 1938, Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain told Parliament that deliberately bombing civilians violated international law. He also said air attacks should be directed at identifiable military targets, with reasonable care to protect civilians nearby. Read the contemporary parliamentary record.
This records the British government's position before the Blitz. It is not a court judgment on every later raid. To assess a particular attack, we need evidence about its targets and methods, and the rules that applied at the time.
Whether an attack broke the laws of war is a separate question from whether it was genocide.
The U-boats: trying to cut Britain's supply lines
Britain is an island. During the war, ships brought it food, fuel and materials from overseas. Without enough supplies, Britain would find it much harder to keep fighting.
Germany attacked those ships with submarines called U-boats. A submarine can travel under water. The name U-boat comes from the German word for an undersea boat.
The aim was to sink ships faster than Britain and its allies could replace them. Cutting these supply lines could weaken Britain and force it to give up. This struggle formed part of the Battle of the Atlantic. Read the Ministry of Defence account of the campaign.

The German submarine U-505 is the low vessel in front of the aircraft carrier USS Guadalcanal. This photograph was taken after the US Navy captured the submarine on 4 June 1944. Photo: US Navy / Naval History and Heritage Command, 80-G-49170. Public domain.
The submarine in this photograph is U-505. The US Navy captured it in June 1944. The picture was taken after its capture, not during an attack.
The danger at sea was real. Sailors on cargo ships faced death while carrying the supplies people needed. Merchant sailors were people working on trading ships, rather than serving as naval crews. Imperial War Museums explains the Battle of the Atlantic and its human cost.
Trying to starve a country into surrender can cause terrible civilian harm. But the U-boat campaign against Britain did not meet the definition of genocide. The evidence shows a campaign to defeat Britain by cutting its supply lines, not an intent to destroy British people as a national group.
What did Nuremberg decide about submarine warfare?
Starvation can still be part of genocide
The last point needs care. It would be wrong to turn it into a rule saying that starvation can never be genocide.
Deliberately depriving a group of food can help destroy it. If people impose those conditions with the required aim of destroying the group, the genocide definition can apply.
It would also be wrong to say that a military goal always rules out genocide. People can have more than one aim. A campaign can seek a military victory and also seek to destroy a group.
That is why we must examine the evidence in each case. We cannot decide just by accepting an attacker's excuse. A UN tribunal explained that other motives can exist alongside genocidal intent.
How we work out what people intended
We cannot look inside a person's mind. Instead, we look at what they said, what they ordered and what they did.
An order can show a plan. A report can show that people carried it out. A pattern of attacks can show who was being selected. Witnesses can explain what they saw and experienced.
One photograph may show damage without showing the whole reason for it. One speech may leave out the real plan. That is why historians and courts compare different pieces of evidence.
For the Holocaust, the evidence comes from many places, including records made by the Nazis themselves. The conclusion does not depend on one image or one person's memory. Read how Holocaust evidence was presented at Nuremberg.
A crime does not have to be genocide to be serious
Genocide is one name in the law. There are others.
War crimes are serious breaches of the rules of war. Crimes against humanity include acts such as murder carried out as part of a widespread or systematic attack on civilians. Systematic means an organised pattern, rather than isolated acts.
An attack may fall into one of these categories without being genocide. Sometimes the same acts can fall into more than one category. The United Nations explains these different crimes.
Saying “this was not genocide” is therefore not the same as saying “this was allowed”. The rules of war still matter. So do the people who were harmed.
We also need to be careful about dates. Today's rules include clear protections for civilians and a ban on using civilian starvation as a method of war. Some of these treaty rules were written after 1945. We should not describe a later treaty as though it already existed during the Blitz.
The difference to remember
In the Holocaust, Jews were murdered because the Nazis aimed to destroy them as a people.
In the Blitz, bombing was used to damage Britain and break its will to fight.
In the U-boat campaign, sinking supply ships was used to weaken Britain and force it to surrender.
We understand these campaigns by studying the evidence about their actions and aims. The number of civilians killed does not, by itself, decide whether an event was genocide.
Every victim was a person. Using the right words helps us explain what happened to them clearly and honestly.
Project Empathy restores historical footage and colourises it using historical research. The original film remains part of the historical record. Our work helps people look more closely at the lives and events it shows.
Sources and photographs
The links throughout this article lead to the research behind each section. They include the Genocide Convention, the Nuremberg judgment, a contemporary parliamentary record, Imperial War Museums and the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum.
The historical photographs have separate captions and credits. They show refugee children, bomb damage and a captured submarine.



