Tu quoque: does “you do it too” answer the criticism?
‘Please return the tools on time,’ says Alex.
‘You returned yours late last week,’ replies Jo.
Jo may have found a real problem with Alex's behaviour. But does that show the return rule is a bad rule?
What does it mean?
Tu quoque means ‘you too’. This fallacy rejects a point by saying the person making it has done the same thing.
It shifts from judging the point to judging the speaker. Those can be two separate questions.
An everyday example
A club asks people to keep receipts for money they spend. Someone objects because the treasurer once lost a receipt.
The treasurer's mistake may need sorting out. It does not show that receipts are useless. They may still help the club keep clear records.

A useful rule and a person's failure to follow it can both deserve attention. One does not settle the other.
Try it yourself
Ask two questions: ‘Is this a useful rule?’ and ‘Has this person followed it?’
Could the answer be yes to the first and no to the second? How could you raise both points fairly?
Think it through
You could say, ‘The rule should apply to you too. Let's also check whether it helps us share the tools fairly.’
That challenges the unfairness without dropping the original question. The rule and the person's behaviour can both be examined.
One important point
Doing the opposite of what you ask others to do can matter. It may affect trust or show that a rule is applied unfairly.
The mistake is treating that as a complete answer to a different claim. A person can fail to follow good advice. That does not make the advice wrong.
A question to keep
Does ‘you do it too’ answer the point, or raise a second issue?
How could this work in a game?
A future Thinky round could ask which question a reply answers and which question it leaves open.
A future Willowwind tool-library quest could involve a keeper who returns tools late. You would seek a fair rule and fair treatment for everyone.
These are ideas for future activities. They are not features you can play now.
Thinky's current free beta is a proof of concept: an early test of the idea. It covers one topic, survivorship bias. That means missing part of the picture by looking only at the examples that made it through.
Willowwind Island is a future 2D adventure concept. It would offer longer stories, exploration and choices. Thinky is being explored as a set of short, brain-training-style challenges.
Project Empathy comes first. Afterwards, we plan to seek help from professional game developers. There is no launch date yet.
Follow the games as they develop
Visit our games page to try the current Thinky prototype. You can also sign up there for occasional project news, testing and launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Sources and further reading
This series was inspired by the School of Thought topic guides. The examples, game ideas and illustrations here are our own.



