top of page

Belief bias: a believable conclusion can hide weak logic

Nov 3
2 min read

Sometimes an answer sounds so sensible that we accept the reasons for it without checking them.


But a claim can sound true even when the steps used to reach it have a gap.


What does it mean?


Belief bias happens when what we believe about an answer affects how we judge the reasoning behind it.


We may accept weak reasoning because we like where it ends. We may also reject good reasoning because the answer surprises us.


An everyday example


Try this: ‘All oak trees are plants. Some plants grow indoors. So some oak trees grow indoors.’


The first two statements do not prove the last one. The indoor plants could all be ferns. We have not been told that any of them are oaks.


A large circle labelled plants contains two separate smaller circles labelled oaks and indoor plants, showing a possible gap in the argument.

This possible arrangement keeps oaks and indoor plants apart. The two starting claims alone do not prove they overlap.


Try it yourself


Draw a large circle for all plants. Inside it, draw one circle for oaks and another for indoor plants.


Can the two small circles stay apart while the first two statements are still true?


Think it through


Yes. Both groups can be plants without sharing any members. The drawing shows a case where the reasons are true but the conclusion does not follow.


Some oaks might grow indoors in real life. You would need separate evidence for that. This particular argument has not shown it.


One important point


There are two useful questions: is the answer true, and do these reasons prove it? They are not the same question.


Knowing facts still matters. It helps you check the starting claims. Just do not let a familiar ending hide a missing step.


A question to keep


Do these reasons really lead to that answer?


How could this work in a game?


A future Thinky round could show the same argument with familiar names and made-up names. You would check whether the reasoning changes.


A future Willowwind mystery could include a convincing story with one missing link. You would map which clues support which parts of the story.


These are ideas for future activities. They are not features you can play now.


Thinky's current free beta is a proof of concept: an early test of the idea. It covers one topic, survivorship bias. That means missing part of the picture by looking only at the examples that made it through.


Willowwind Island is a future 2D adventure concept. It would offer longer stories, exploration and choices. Thinky is being explored as a set of short, brain-training-style challenges.


Project Empathy comes first. Afterwards, we plan to seek help from professional game developers. There is no launch date yet.


Follow the games as they develop


Visit our games page to try the current Thinky prototype. You can also sign up there for occasional project news, testing and launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.



Sources and further reading


This series was inspired by the School of Thought topic guides. The examples, game ideas and illustrations here are our own.



 
 
bottom of page