top of page

Ambiguity: when the meaning changes halfway through

4 days ago
2 min read

‘This room is light. Light things are easy to carry. So this room is easy to carry.’


The joke works because ‘light’ changes meaning. First it means bright. Then it means not heavy.


What does it mean?


Ambiguity means that words can have more than one meaning. It becomes a reasoning problem when an argument slips between those meanings.


Using the same word does not always mean we are talking about the same idea.


An everyday example


A notice says entry to a show is ‘free’. Someone decides this means anyone can enter at any time, with no rules.


But ‘free’ may mean there is no ticket price. The show can still have opening hours and a limit on how many people fit inside.


Sunlight illustrates light meaning bright. A feather illustrates light meaning low in weight.

Sunlight and a light feather use different meanings of the word. An argument cannot quietly swap between them.


Try it yourself


Read this claim: ‘The club is open, so there cannot be a roof.’


Which two meanings of ‘open’ have been mixed up? Rewrite the first part so its meaning is clear.


Think it through


‘Open’ can mean welcoming visitors or physically uncovered. A club can be open to visitors inside a building with a roof.


‘The club is open to visitors today’ removes the confusion. Using that wording makes the gap in the argument easier to see.


One important point


An unclear word is not proof that someone is trying to mislead you. People may use a word differently or leave out a detail by mistake.


Ask what they mean before arguing. Then use the same clear meaning at each step. If the argument stops working, the switch may have been doing the work.


A question to keep


Does this word mean the same thing all the way through?


How could this work in a game?


A future Thinky round could ask you to spot a word that changes meaning and choose a clearer sentence.


A future Willowwind noticeboard quest could involve a confusing permit. You would ask what its terms mean before deciding what it allows.


These are ideas for future activities. They are not features you can play now.


Thinky's current free beta is a proof of concept: an early test of the idea. It covers one topic, survivorship bias. That means missing part of the picture by looking only at the examples that made it through.


Willowwind Island is a future 2D adventure concept. It would offer longer stories, exploration and choices. Thinky is being explored as a set of short, brain-training-style challenges.


Project Empathy comes first. Afterwards, we plan to seek help from professional game developers. There is no launch date yet.


Follow the games as they develop


Visit our games page to try the current Thinky prototype. You can also sign up there for occasional project news, testing and launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.



Sources and further reading


This series was inspired by the School of Thought topic guides. The examples, game ideas and illustrations here are our own.



 
 
bottom of page